How to Build a Buyer List for M&A That Actually Gets Responses

Introduction

You’ve built what feels like the perfect buyer list. Dozens—maybe hundreds—of contacts, carefully researched, neatly formatted. You hit send on your teaser and wait for the flood of responses.

Instead? Silence.

If that sounds familiar, you’re not alone. M&A professionals spend nearly 40% of their time on deal sourcing, yet most buyer lists yield response rates below 5%. The issue usually isn’t the deal—it’s how the list is built. Too many look more like phone books than precision tools.

Here’s how to build a buyer list that actually gets responses—the kind that lands meetings, drives engagement, and moves deals forward.

TL;DR

Stop building generic buyer lists. Focus on strategic fit, segment buyers into tiers, and map the actual decision makers. An ideal list is focused—often a few dozen high-fit buyers instead of a massive catch-all export. Quality beats quantity every single time.

Why Most Buyer Lists Fail

A common mistake is assuming more names equals more opportunities. In practice, that almost always backfires.

I’ve seen advisors spend weeks building a 200-name list that barely moved the needle, while a tighter list of 15–50 highly qualified buyers led to multiple meetings. Why? Because focus matters. Buyers can tell when outreach is targeted versus when it’s just a blast.

And let’s be honest—buyers don’t have time for another generic teaser that looks like it went to 200 people. They hit delete.

The Mindset Shift

Stop thinking about “building buyer lists.” Start thinking about building buyer ecosystems.

The SPARK Framework for Building Better Buyer Lists

Over time, I’ve found a framework that consistently works. I call it SPARK:

S – Strategic Fit Analysis

Before adding a name, ask why this buyer would actually care. What gap does your deal fill for them?

Questions to guide you:

What markets is the buyer trying to enter?
What capabilities are they missing?
What deals have they done recently that signal their strategy?
What competitive threats are they facing?

P – Precedent Research

The best predictor of future M&A activity is past activity. Buyers who’ve done similar transactions in the last 24 months are far more likely to engage again.

Pro tip: Don’t just look at the winners. Track buyers who showed up in past processes but didn’t close. They’re often the hungriest next time around.

A – Authority Mapping

This is where most lists collapse. You’ve got the right company but the wrong contact.

Decision-maker mapping by buyer type:

Strategics (<$1B revenue): CEO or COO
Strategics (>$1B revenue): VP of Corporate Development or equivalent
Private Equity (<$500M AUM): Managing Partner or Principal
Private Equity (>$500M AUM): VP or Associate (with a Partner looped in)

R – Relationship Leverage

Great lists aren’t just contacts—they’re relationship maps. Before you go cold, check:

Board connections
Trusted advisors (lawyers, accountants, consultants)
Industry peers or alumni ties

K – Knowledge Validation

Make sure every buyer on the list has the capacity and intent to transact. Too many lists include buyers that are still integrating a recent acquisition or are on the sidelines.

Segmenting Buyers: A 3-Tier Targeting Strategy

Not every buyer should get the same level of attention. Break your list into tiers:

Tier 1: Premium Prospects (5–10 buyers)
Highest-probability targets. Personalized outreach, custom materials, and multi-touch follow-ups.
Tier 2: Strong Contenders (15–25 buyers)
Good strategic fit with active deal history. Semi-personalized outreach.
Tier 3: Wild Cards (10–15 buyers)
Potential fits who may surprise you—new entrants, adjacent sector buyers, or opportunistic investors.

4 Buyer List Mistakes That Tank Response Rates

Spray and Pray – Sending the same teaser to 200+ names = low engagement.
Ignoring Timing – Pitching a buyer right after they closed a big acquisition almost never works.
Only Targeting the Obvious – Some of the best exits come from unexpected buyers.
Skipping International Buyers – Global acquirers often pay premium multiples for U.S. access.

Advanced Techniques to Find Strategic Buyers

Ecosystem Mapping

Look beyond direct competitors:

Suppliers seeking vertical integration
Customers wanting supply security
Adjacent technology providers
Consolidators rolling up fragmented markets

Disruption Analysis

Who is being disrupted by your target’s model? Those incumbents are often the hungriest buyers.

Capacity Timing Model

Track where buyers are in their M&A cycle (typically 12–18 months). Hit them at the right moment and your odds improve dramatically.

Key Insight: A good buyer list isn’t just long. It’s focused, relevant, and well-timed.

Best Tools to Build Buyer Lists

Today, the best bankers use a mix of judgment and technology.

Essential tools:

M&A databases to track deal activity
Financial screens to validate capacity
Social listening for strategy signals
AI-powered matching to identify non-obvious buyers based on fit

The tech doesn’t replace expertise—it augments it.

Tracking and Improving Buyer List Performance

The best teams treat buyer list building as iterative. Track:

Response rates by tier
Meetings booked
Buyers who stick through diligence
Time to first response

Each deal makes your next list stronger.

The Future of Buyer Discovery

M&A is changing fast. The most competitive processes are already seeing:

AI-driven buyers acquiring automation capabilities
Cross-border activity from international players
Non-traditional buyers like family offices and sovereign wealth funds entering the mix

The edge goes to advisors who adapt—and who build smarter ecosystems, not bigger spreadsheets.

Final Take: Build Smarter Buyer Relationships

Your buyer list is your edge. The difference between a good deal and a great one often comes down to the one buyer who sees unique value in your target.

The best advisors don’t just build lists. They build relationships. They know today’s pass could be tomorrow’s perfect buyer.

Ready to Supercharge Your Buyer Research?

PrivSource’s AI Researcher builds curated buyer lists of potential acquirers, ranked by strategic fit. Each list surfaces the right decision makers with verified contact info—so you can move from research to outreach in minutes.

Try AI Researcher for free and save hours on your next list.

Ready to improve your buyer outreach?

Try AI Researcher for Free

No credit card required. Cancel anytime.